...6-foot-6, 320-pound Haynesworth stomped on Dallas Cowboys center Andre Gurode's head Oct. 1, knocking off his helmet, then kicked and stomped his face. Gurode needed 30 stitches to repair the cuts left by the tackle's cleats...For this he was suspended for five games??? FIVE GAMES??
- He stomped on Gurode's head, knocking off Gurode's helmet.
- He kicked and stomped Gurode's face.
- Gurode needed 30 stitches.
However....
One reason to let him play again after five games is that his next best income-earning opportunity might be to earn maybe $50K per year. Given that Gurode has been disfigured, he surely has a case against Haynesworth for an intentional tort and should sue the guy. But how can Haynesworth pay any damages if he doesn't play football? So maybe letting him play is one way of (potentially) providing compensation for Gurode.
Update #1: Ken Schram agrees (also see Pooh's comment):
I, for one, am underwhelmed. ...Update #2: I have just written more on the subject at The Sports Economist.
There were probably at least two-dozen uniformed police officers at that Sunday game when Haynesworth deliberately planted his cleated foot on Andre Gurode's face.
I'd sure like to know why a couple of them didn't flip Haynesworth to the ground, cuff his hands behind his back and take him in on assault charges.
What Haynesworth did was wayyyy beyond "unsportsmanlike conduct."
It was a crime.





If John Palmer stomped on my face in the U.S. for writing yet one more outrageous comment on his blog, I'm sure he'd be charged in nothing flat, so why hasn't Haynesworth been charged?
You honestly imagine that Haynesworth hasn't already socked away a fortune?
The famously astute journalist, author, social and political commentator, TV and radio personality, and health expert, Stephen Pollard, on a similar incident in the UK recently:
Charge the thug Thatcher
http://www.stephenpollard.net/002850.html
(Stephen, if you are reading this, I expect a very large cheque for promoting you so shamelessly)
"How the hell does that get excused simply because it took place on a football field?"
What I wrote on Pollard's blog (linked above) in answer to a question about violence in sports:
"Why should people be able to get away with saying things on the internet that they'd be locked up for in real life?
For one reason or another the soccer pitch and the internet have become sacred ground, a place where the authorities fear to tread.
Rock stars are for the most part similarly protected against any kind of public sanction for their behaviour. Thus, Mick Jagger shtups 20-year-old girl and the reaction is: "Wow, those rockers, ain't that the life?" Any other man in his mid-sixties shtups 20-year-old girl and the reaction on the front page of every tabloid is: "Dirty old man! There should be laws against this!" And why wasn't the odious Ozzy Osbourne locked up for possession of illegal substances years ago? (Sharon should be behind bars simply for existing.)"
Lord Denning, the famous English judge, once make the following remark: "Be you ever so high, the law is always above you." Law perhaps, but justice is invariably a different matter, most especially if the individual in question is a citizen of the United States and a highly-paid football player. Indeed, in the same way that the bureaucrat Eichmann was far more guilty than the individuals who actually manned the gas chambers, those responsible for upholding justice in the Haynesworth incident are even more culpable than the despicable bastard who carried out the attack in the first place and has now got off scot-free as a result of their criminally negligent indifference.
write,
"Nashville police and the district attorney contacted the Cowboys' general counsel, offering their assistance to Gurode in prosecuting Haynesworth. The Cowboys declined to comment on the suspension."
Why should Gurode be forced to bring the prosecution though? And that's certainly what that passage above appears to be suggesting.
How far can we take this? Would it be possible, for example, to improve the grades of students by fining professors for poor grades? How about executing professors for poor grades?